In the first part of this series (Online Art Critique: Giving Criticism), we looked at how to provide respectful, honest criticism when someone offers up a work of art for review. We also discussed ways to give constructive criticism and avoid unhelpful comments that could be misinterpreted by the artist. Now, we want to dive into the process of taking criticism. How do you seek help for those artistic roadblocks?
No One is Above Criticism
I have seen artists post work for critique that honestly believe there’s nothing wrong with what they’ve done. Their work is infallible and they fully expect other artists to recognize the inherent greatness of what’s being shared. The reason the art is posted is to simply inflate the ego of the creator and collect what are frequently referred to as “ass pats” – those “Wow, amazing, great job!” comments that don’t really convey any deep emotional connection with the work. The result of this behavior is never pleasant, especially after the first glaring fault in the composition, color theory, anatomy, etc. is pointed out. It’s always downhill from there.
If you understand that a work of art is never finished, only abandoned, then you’ll see that there’s always room for improvement. Some pieces could be pushed further than where an artist left off. Some may be pushed too far and could benefit from editing in composition or technique. If one work seems to miss the mark, take the comments you’ve received and apply them to your future projects.
Be thankful if you receive honest criticism. Many artists don’t receive the helpful comments and serious feedback that would help them become stronger creators. Don’t run and hide from criticism.
Separate Yourself From Your Art
Exposing yourself to criticism is never easy, even when you know you need help. Remind yourself that critiques aren’t about attacking you, the artist. They’re about helping you grow by pointing out ways your art is on track for success and ways it could use improvement. No matter how much blood and sweat you pour into a piece – no matter how much it might represent you as an individual – you need to separate comments about your art from comments about you.
Ask For What You Want
Too often artists will post work that they want reviewed, but don’t explain what problems they’re encountering or where they feel lost. If you don’t ask for help on specific areas, you can’t be surprised if you receive all sorts of comments – especially those comments that don’t have anything to do with where you really need assistance. Explain what you’re trying to do and ask those that volunteer to critique your work to recommend solutions for particular areas.
You’ll still receive a few off-task comments now and then, but you’ll find the majority of the responses are focused on the answers you’re looking for.
Bad Response: Let It Go
Some forums have trolls that delight in waiting for an artist to post work for the sole purpose of attacking the art. Some forums have members that just can’t seem to wrap their heads around communication techniques and leave replies that come off as heavy-handed comments or blatant attacks. Here’s a rule you should try to follow: You don’t have to respond to every reply.
If someone leaves you a bad critique, thank the member for the response and leave it at that. It’s better to stomp around or punch invisible ninjas in your studio for an hour or two than ignite a heated discussion or respond with an attack of your own. Not only is such behavior unprofessional, it is often the response many trolls are looking to elicit. It’s best to err on the side of being the bigger person than risk damaging your credibility with an off-the-cuff remark or heated exchange.
Recognize Good Critics
Every art space has a collection of respectful, level-headed members that want to help their community grow and promote creative development. Some are professionals working in the industry. Others are up-and-coming talents or hobbyists who enjoy creating in their freetime. Make a point to thank these members when they respond to your work. Let them know that you value their input and appreciate the time they’re taking away from their own projects to help you develop yours.
These are just a few recommendations to help you on your path as an artist. You’ve probably discovered many on your own and will discover even more as you continue to expose your work to different art communities. Good luck and keep creating.
King Unicorn is a guest blogger here at Grimvisions. You can see more of his work at http://kingunicorn.blogspot.com/
